For Massenet on his birthday: a small survey of some of his operas

Jules Massenet was the most prolific and, artistically as well as commercially, also the most successful French opera composer between 1870/71 and World War I, the belle Epoque of the Third French Republic. He is best known for his operas, of which he wrote more than thirty. The two most frequently staged are Manon and Werther



Jules Massenet’s Manon has, since its now legendary performance starring Anna Netrebko and Rolando Villazon (Berlin, April 2007), become a real hype. Anyone who had ever seen the performance could sincerely ask, like Verdi’s Ford (‘Falstaff’): ‘e sogno o realta’?

It was a reality that turned out to be a dream after all, as Netrebko found a new love, leaving Villazon with heart and voice problems. It was also not entirely clear until the last day of rehearsals whether he would sing the, scheduled for June 2007, performances of Manon in Barcelona.

He did come, and although he sang below his usual level, he managed to completely convince everyone with his acting and (sometimes a little too) intense commitment. His Manon is brilliantly portrayed by a spectacularly singing and acting, Lulu-like, Natalie Dessay.

Manuel Lanza is a fine Lescaut, but for Samuel Ramey, a singer I greatly admire, Comte des Grieux unfortunately comes too late in his career.

The mise-en-scène and character direction by David McVicar, for me still really one of the best contemporary directors, were more than excellent. The costumes were beautiful to behold and the (traditional) staging was often really surprising, all the more so as McVicar managed to give it a contemporary twist from time to time.

As a bonus, you do get a ‘peek inside’. Through a truly fascinating documentary, you can follow the stars during their rehearsals with McVicar.


In 1902, ten years after the premiere, Massenet produced a new version of his Werther, this at the request of Italian baritone Mattia Battistini, who was eager to sing the lead role. Massenet did not change the key, but rewrote the vocal lines of Werther’s music, making the arias, ‘Pourquoi me réveiller’ included, barely recognisable.

The “baritone version” of the opera was and remains an oddity; no original manuscript of the score even exists. In recent times, with its penchant for ever new challenges, there was also an increased interest in alternative versions of well-known operas. The baritones, tired of singing the villains, are rediscovering the repertoire, in which they can release all their lyrical melancholy.

Thomas Hampson has always been an explorer of lesser-known paths and he first performed the role of Werther back in 1989. In 2004, he sang a concert performance of it at the Paris Chatelet, and that performance has been released by Virgin on two DVDs. He does an excellent job, but the manic-depressive is a bit off.

His Charlotte is sublimely sung by Susan Graham, who also performed the role in Amsterdam some years ago, where she moved the audience and press to tears. Michel Plasson has all the drama at his fingertips as you can hear.

“Pourquoi me réveiller” by three tenors

Alain Vanzo :

Sergei Lemeshev in Russian:

Jonas Kaufmann:

Piotr Beczala:



Who does not know ‘Méditation’, the sentimentally sweet but oh-so-beautiful piece of violin music? Most often it will make you cry.

Méditation in Josef Hassid’s performance:

However, not many people have ever heard, let alone seen, the opera in which this piece acts as a kind of interlude in the second act.

Recordings of the complete work are still scarce, I only know of three myself (with Anna Moffo, Beverly Sills and Renée Fleming), of which the one with Sills, Sherrill Milnes and Nicolai Gedda (Warner 0190295869069) is dearest to me.

Below Beverly Sills and Sherrill Milnes in the final scene of the opera:

DVD from La Fenice

Pier Luigi Pizzi’s production from La Fenice had previously been released on CD and I found it particularly strong musically and mainly vocally. I was therefore particularly curious as to whether the visuals added anything to it on Dynamic’s DVD. To which I can now say a resounding “yes”.

The sets are sparse, yet the stage seems to be completely full of them. Because of the colours (with very predominant red) perhaps, but also because of the dominant place they occupy on stage. For instance, Thaïs’ rose-covered bed, on which she – as if she were the Venus of Urbino or one of the versions of Danaë, also by Titian – lies very voluptuously. This bed is very prominently in the centre of the stage.

In the third act, when the fun life has ended and the penance begins, the roses are nowhere to be seen (a bed of thorns?) and her posture is as chaste as her white robe.

The costumes are a story apart: very opulent, oriental and barely concealing. Eva Mei doesn’t go as far as her colleague Carol Neblett, who went completely out of her clothes in New Orleans in 1973, but her see-through little nothing of a dress, from which her breasts keep escaping almost unnoticed, leaves nothing to the imagination.

Perhaps she was inspired by the very first Thaïs, Sybil Sanderson, whose breasts were also ‘accidentally’ visible during the premiere performance in 1894? Then again, it is all about the greatest (and most beautiful) courtesan in Alexandria!

Eva Mei is very virtuoso and very convincing as Thaïs . So is Michele Pertusi as Athanael. There is a lot of ballet, though. Also where it really shouldn’t be, which is very distracting at times.

Thaïs from Toronto: unearthly beautiful orchestral playing

Recordings of Thaïs are still scarce so any new releases are more than welcome. Especially if the performance is good, and this new recording on Chandos most certainly is. At least: to some extent.

The Toronto orchestra sounds so incredibly beautiful that you cannot help falling in love with it. Sir Andrew Davis truly extracts the impossible from his musicians: I have not heard the score performed so beautifully before. The pianissimi, the way they manage the quiet passages to perfection, the subcutaneous tension. Hats off! Hats off also to the violinist who manages to add new layers to the ‘Meditation’. So beautiful!

Unfortunately, the singers lag a bit behind. Erin Wall is a beautiful soprano with a crystal-clear voice, but a ‘Whore of Babylon’? More like a rather childishly naive girl.

Joshua Hopkins has the right voice for Athanael but he goes the wrong way when it comes to ‘earthly desires’. Andrew Staples is a good Nicias but he too fails to fully convince me.


A fairy tale has its own rules. Much is interchangeable, but what must never be compromised is the “happy ending”. So: the ugly duckling becomes a beautiful swan and Cinderella becomes a princess. All evil spirits are punished and we can sleep peacefully.

Sometimes I pray to those I don’t really believe in: give us back our fairy tales, because these days everything has to be totally true to nature and as realistic as possible. Fortunately, my prayers are sometimes heard and so it came to pass that I was able to enjoy an old-fashioned evening; with my cat on my lap and Cinderella on my screen.

Laurent Pelly is undoubtedly one of the best contemporary directors: he puts a modern spin on everything he does, but he stays true to the libretto and the music. In the process, his staging is extraordinarily witty. As is the delightful Cendrillon, recorded at London’s Royal Opera House in 2011.

I no longer need to recommend Joyce DiDonato (Cendrillon) to anyone – she is easily the greatest ‘zwischenfach singer’ of our time. Ewa Podleś is a more than delightful stepmother and Alice Coote the most charming ‘Prince Charmant’. And to this you may add the truly idiomatic conductor (Bertrand de Billy)….
Life really can be beautiful sometimes

Trailer of the productie


Richard Strauss composed his world hit Salome to a play by Oscar Wilde; and the latter drew his inspiration from a short story by Flaubert, ‘Herodias’. Paul Milliet and Henri Grémont also based their libretto for Massenet’s opera Herodiade on this story. Neither Wilde nor Milliet and Grémont were very faithful to Flaubert. Whereas the French novelist more or less limited himself to the biblical narrative, enriched with his poetic language and descriptions, the playwright and librettists added entirely new aspects and twists to the story.

Hérodiade was first performed in the Royal Theatre of Brussels on 19 December 1881. Anyone expecting animal eroticism, blood and sweat, as with Richard Strauss, will be disappointed. Massenet’s Salome is a truly innocent and devout girl. When her mother left her to marry Hérode, she was given shelter by Jean (John the Baptist), with whom she fell in love. A love that proved to be mutual.

No opera is complete without complications: Hérode has a crush on Salome, Hérodiade becomes jealous of her and Jean is beheaded. Salome sees Hérodiade as the instigator of all evil and wants to kill her. Hérodiade whispers “I am your mother” and Salome commits suicide.

The music already exudes a hint of the perfume of Massenet’s later works, but with all those choruses, exotic Oriental scenes and elaborate ballet scenes, it is nothing less than a real Grand Opera in the best Meyerbeer tradition.

One of the earliest recorded fragments of the opera is, I think, the famous aria of Hérode ‘Vision Fusitive’ by the French baritone Maurice Renaud, made in 1908:

And from the recording Georges Thill made in 1927, we know what an ideal Jean should sound like:

Regine Crespin 1963

If you are in possession of this performance, you need look no further. It doesn’t get any better than this. There is only one problem: this recording does not exist. At least not of the complete opera.

In 1963, EMI recorded the highlights of Hérodiade with the best French singers of the time (and of today, for that matter) and the answer to the “why not complete ????” will probably never be given.

Georges Prêtre conducts the orchestra of the Theater National de Paris as if his life depends upon it and every role is more than excellently cast.

Regine Crespin sings ‘Il est doux, il est bon’:

Regine Crespin’s Salomé is unequalled and so is Rita Gorr’s Hérodiade. Albert Lance (Jean) shows how that role should really be sung in the tradition of Georges Thill, and for Michel Dens as Hérode we really cannot find the right words. Such singers no longer exist.

Hopefully, Warner will one day release the recording on CD.

Montserrat Caballé (Barcelona 1984)

 This recording also may only be obtained via a pirate (or You Tube), but then it is complete and moreover with (admittedly bad) images!

Dunja Vejzovic portrays a deliciously mean Hérodiade and Juan Pons is a somewhat youthful but otherwise fine Hérode. A few years later, he will become one of the best “Hérodes” and you can already hear and see that in this recording.

Montserrat Caballé is a fantastic Salomé, the voice alone makes you believe you are in heaven and José Carreras is very moving as a charismatic Jean.

Below, Carreras sings ‘Ne pouvant réprimer les élans’:

None of the protagonists is really idiomatic, but what a pleasure it is to watch a real Diva (and Divo)! They really don’t make them like that any more

The whole opera on you tube:

Reneée Fleming 1994

In the mid-1990s, Herodiade enjoyed a short-lived revival. The opera was then performed in several opera houses and it was even recorded – officially – three times: once in the studio and twice live.

I must admit that I was a bit concerned about Gergiev as the director, but he really did an excellent job. Under his baton the opera sounds like a real Grand Opéra, grand, fiery and compelling.

Plácido Domingo (Jean) is perhaps a touch too heroic, but his voice sounds youthful and contageous, worthy of a true prophet.

Personally, I find Dolora Zajick (Hérodiade) a bit on the (too) heavy side, but her singing is undeniably excellent and there is nothing wrong with her interpretation.

Juan Pons is an excellent Hérode, but I would have liked Phanuel (Kenneth Cox) to be a bit more idiomatic. Something that also applies to the Salomé of Renée Fleming: she sings beautifully but in this role she can not totally convince me.

Nancy Gustafson 1995

The performance in Vienna was highly praised, and that this praise was justified is proved by the recording made live in the house by ORF.

First of all, there is Agnes Baltsa’s brilliant title role: fierce and dramatic. If you ask me: apart from Rita Gorr probably the best Hérodiade ever.

Placido Domingo sings ‘Ne pouvant réprimer les élans’:

Domingo, in the role of Jean, is even more impressive here than on Sony and also Juan Pons (Hérode) actually convinces me yet more on this recording. His rendition of ‘Vision Fugitive’ is very, very moving. Unfortunately, Nancy Gustafson (Salomé) must acknowledge the superiority of Fleming (Sony), but both pale in comparison to Cheryl Studer (Warner). Not to mention Regine Crespin!

Judging by the photos in the text booklet and the sparse clips on YouTube, we should be glad that the recording appeared on CD and not on DVD.

Finale of the opera:

In any case, the sound is excellent and the Vienna Opera orchestra under the direction of Marcello Viotti plays with great passion.

Cheryl Studer 1995

Orchestrally, this recording is really top-notch. Michel Plasson conducts the orchestra from Toulouse very energetically, with a lot of verve and drive, and he also knows how to allow space for all the subtleties. Exciting and beautiful. That is how I like to hear opera.

José van Dam is an impressive Phanuel and Nadine Denize an excellent Hérodiade., although her intonation is not always pure.

Hérode is not really a role for Thomas Hampson, but he sings it very beautifully. Something that unfortunately cannot be said of Ben Heppner’s Jean. A heroic tenor in that role is nothing but a terrible mistake.

Cheryl Studer, on the other hand, is a Salomé of everyone’s dreams: girlish, innocent and naive. Her voice shines and sways and her final words “Ah! Darned Queen, if it is true that your cursed loins have given birth to me, look! Take back your blood and my life!” leave you shuddering and desperately weeping. Brava.

Over Victoria de los Angeles, madonna onder operazangeressen.

de los Angeles

Victoria de los Angeles was zonder twijfel één van de mooiste lyrische sopranen van haar generatie. Zij debuteerde in 1945 in het Liceu in Barcelona als de Grafin in Le Nozze di Figaro. Haar internationale doorbraak kwam toen zij in 1948 voor de BBC optrad als Salud in La vida breve van Manuel de Falla, een rol die ze voor het eerst scenisch vertolkte tijdens het Holland Festival in 1953.

de los angeles Salud

Eén jaar later zong zij Marguerite in Faust van Gounod in Parijs en daarna kwamen alle grote podia in de hele wereld

Haar echte naam was Victoria Lopez Garcia. Waarom ze ‘de los Angeles’ als haar toneelnaam had gekozen? Ach, zo belangrijk is het ook weer niet, maar het paste haar als een handschoen. Niet alleen zag ze eruit als een Spaanse Madonna, ook haar stem was engelachtig: bloedmooi en van een onschuldige schoonheid. Iets wat haar minder geschikt maakte voor sommige rollen, zoals bij voorbeeld Violetta. Niet dat het slecht was, maar het klonk wel heel erg kuis.


En toch was zij één van de beste Manons (Massenet), ook niet het voorbeeld van een ‘fatsoenlijke’ vrouw:

Ook haar vertolking van Carmen is waanzinnig goed. Niet hoerig en niet zo zelfverzekerd, maar o zo aantrekkelijk!

Haar stem was niet alleen lyrisch, warm en delicaat maar ook zeer aristocratisch, waardoor haar Mimi en Cio Cio San behalve broos en hulpeloos iets koninklijks kregen en zelfs Santuzza verrijkt werd met een beetje nobiliteit.

Maar de los Angeles was meer dan alleen een operadiva. Behalve in opera’s trad zij veelvuldig op als concertzangeres op en was een zeer begenadigd liedzangeres. Er wordt over haar verteld, dat zij aan het begin van haar carrière, vóór ze in een opera ging optreden, erop stond om eerst een liedrecital te geven. Zo kon zij zich eerst aan het publiek voorstellen als de echte Victoria en niet als een operapersonage.

Haar repertoire was onvoorstelbaar groot. Zij zong Italiaanse, Spaanse, Franse en Duitse liederen en wist als geen ander op alles wat zij zong een eigen stempel te drukken. Haar Brahms en Mendelssohn zijn onweerstaanbaar, en bij haar ‘Ich Liebe Dich’ van Grieg wordt men vanzelf verliefd.

Haar liefdevolle, ietwat zoetige timbre, haar souplesse en haar vermogen om woorden te kleuren maakten haar bijzonder geschikt voor het Franse repertoire. Haar Debussy, haar Ravel, haar Delibes (luister maar even naar ‘Les filles de Cadiz’!) zijn werkelijk ongeëvenaard.

Voor het Spaanse lied had ze net zoveel betekend als Fischer-Dieskau voor het Duitse of  Peter Pears voor het Engelse. Zij zong werkelijk alles, wat in haar vaderland werd gecomponeerd: beginnend met de middeleeuwse liederen en sefardische romanceros en eindigend in zarzuelas en hedendaagse composities.

Hopelijk is deze album nog steeds te koop.

Victoria de los Angeles
The very best of
Warner Classics 5758882 (2 cd’s)

Manon-Premiere Oper Zürich 7.4.2019: Man hat schon Schlimmeres gesehen

Manon Zurich

Text Mordechai Aranowicz


Die Premiere von Jules Massenets Oper Manon am Opernhaus Zürich geriet zu einer etwas zwiespältigen Angelegenheit, bei der der Funke nicht so recht überspringen wollte. Das lag zum einen sicherlich am Dirigat von Marco Armiliato, der Massenets Musik wenig französisch, weitgehend spannungsarm, sowie farb- und leidenschaftslos abspulte. Im Mittelpunkt der Aufführung stand dagegen Piotr Beczala als des Grieux, dessen Auftritte an seinem einstigen Züricher Stammhaus selten geworden sind.

Beczala, der die Rolle 2011 bereits an der Met an der Seite von Anna Netrebko gesungen hatte, überzeugte rundum mit seinem in allen Lagen perfekt geführtem Tenor und charmantem Spiel, besonders in der Kirchenszene des dritten Aktes. Er versuchte, dem insgesamt sehr trägen Bühnengeschehen etwas Leben einzuhauchen. Dass Beczala dem des Grieux stimmlich  eigentlich bereits entwachsen ist, war bei einem Sänger, der demnächst den Radames in sein Repertoire aufnehmen wird, nicht anders zu erwarten.

Elsa Dreisig brauchte in der Titelrolle einige Zeit um stimmlich warm zu werden, überzeugte dann allerdings im Cours de la Reine-Bild mit glockenhellen Koloraturen, Darstellerisch blieb die Sängerin allerdings leider über weite Strecken blass.

Blass und stimmlich wenig präsent waren auch Yuriy Yurchuk als Lescaut, Eric Huchet als Guillot de Morfontaine und Alastair Miles als Comte des Grieux. Letzterer sang seinen Part  mit den Resten, seines einst so imposanten Basses.  Die übrigen Rollen waren insgesamt solide bis sehr gut besetzt.

Das am Premierenabend so wenig Stimmung aufkam lag auch an der Inszenierung von Floris Visser. Anders als bei zahlreichen Neuinszenierungen tat Visser dem Werk keine Gewalt an und überliess der Musik den Vorrang. Warum man jedoch, das Werk aus dem 18. Jahundert in die Enstehungszeit der Oper verlegen musste blieb unklar und erschien insgesamt ein eher willkürlicher Einfall, der nichts zum tieferen Verständnis der Oper beitrug.

Manon Zurich 1

Das Bühnenbild von Dieuweke van Reij war insgesamt funktional und machte es Dank Deckelung den Sängern akustisch einfach. Leider blieb dieser Rahmen jedoch insgesamt ziemlich stimmungslos, wozu auch die eintönige Lichtregie von Alex Brook verantwortlich war. Die auch von der Bühnenbildnerin entworfenen Kostüme waren zwar ästhetisch, grenzten die einzelnen Charaktere aber untereinander zu wenig ab, sodass gerade die Nebenrollen in den Massenszenen teilweise untergingen und man in diesen Momenten die Sänger in der Masse kaum wahrnahm. Hier wäre eine geschicktere Personenregie von Chor und Statisten wünschenswert gewesen.

Am Ende gab es für alle Beteiligten freundlichen Applaus, der nur für Elsa Dreisig und Piotr Beczala deutlich zunahm, beim Erscheinen des Regieteams dagegen deutlich abnahm. Buhrufe gab es jedoch keine.

Fazit: Diese Inszenierung ist zwar kein Ärgernis, aber auch nicht wirklich gut. Immerhin erhalten die Sänger der Hauptrollen genug Freiraum ihre Rollen zu gestalten, wobei sich das ganze Ensemble noch einspielen muss.