Don’t be alarmed! It is not a rather weird performance of – or a variation on – Beethoven’s fifth symphony but the beginning of Zemlinsky’s 1934 Sinfonietta, a work in which the composer is barely recognizable. I read somewhere that he wanted to prove to his greatest critics that, in the symphonic genre, he was not inferior to the three big Bs: Beethoven, Brahms and Bruckner.
Zemlinsky’s Sinfonietta played Gürzenich-Orchester Köln/ James Conlon
Total nonsense, of course, because his greatest appeal greatly depends on his very own idiom: a sultry, barely-there erotic tension. And the Sinfonietta lacks, precisely, those essential elements. I had not heard the work before and I don’t think I will often listen to it again, but that is not down to the excellent performance: Finnish conductor Susanna Mälkki clearly has an affinity with it.
Unfortunately, the performance of the “Sechs Maeterlinck Gesänge” is not on the same level. This is mainly because of Petra Lang. I have never been a big fan of hers but here she sounds, how shall I put it… anything but erotic? Too bad.
And for ˜dessert” we get the prelude and monologue from the third act of ” König Kandaules”, an opera Zemlinsky never finished. The monologue is very impressively sung by Siegfried Lorenz and the orchestra conducted by Gerd Albrecht, who died in 2014, sounds simply heavenly. The recording dates from 1992.
Alexander Zemlinsky
Sinfonietta, op. 23, Six Maeterlinck-Songs Op. 13
Petra Lang (soprano)
ORF Vienna Radio Symphony Orchestra olv Susanna Mälkki
Der König Kandaules (two excerpts)
Siegfried Lorenz (baritone),
ORF Vienna Radio Symphony Orchestra conducted by Gerd Albrecht
Basia con fuoco 