Entry of the Gods into Valhalla
There is no shortage of recordings of the complete Ring – let alone the individual parts- but apparently the need (among consumers or conductors?) is inexhaustible. Because: you haven’t had time to properly listen to one version or a new one is already being presented.
Simon Rattle is no novice when it comes to Wagner. Between 2006 and 2010, he conducted the complete Ring cycle in both Aix-en-Provence and Bayreuth. But ˜everything the conductor Sir Simon Rattle touches turns to gold”, and thus Das Rheingold was put back on the music stands, this time with the Symphonieorchester des Bayerischen Rundfunks. There, Rattle conducted a concert performance of the first Ring part in April 2015, and it has been released on the orchestra’s own label.
Like Rattle, Jaap van Zweden is a master as to conducting Wagner. His interpretations of his operas with the Radio Philharmonic Orchestra were very well received by critics and audiences alike. The Ring was the logical next step. The choice of orchestra – Van Zweden brought the music to his own Hong Kong Philharmonic – was also obvious. Now that his Das Rheingold is out: shall we compare it with Rattle?
Tomasz Konieczny as Alberich © Wiener Staatsoper/Michael Poehn
The performance under Rattle is carried by the two bass-baritones: Michael Volle (Wotan) and Tomasz Konieczny (Alberich). The latter in particular manages to impress me. His voice is so big that I am almost blown away by it, and the way he manages to put a sly deviousness in his voice is more than sublime. Compared to him, Van Sweden’s Peter Sidhom is nothing more than a ˜character”. Exquisite singing, yes, but he lacks finesse.
Bildquelle: picture alliance / Geisler-Fotopress | Thomas Bartilla/Geisler-Fotopres
Michael Volle’s voice, despite a good dose of pleasant lyricism, also has something compelling about it. Truly a supreme being who has to be obeyed. Matthias Goerne cannot match that. Although I really like his voice, he sounds like he is singing oratorio.
The giants with Rattle – Peter Rose (Fasolt) and Eric Halfvarson (Fafner) – are so insanely good that the basses with Van Zweden – the surely not insignificant Kwangchul Youn and Stephen Milling – have trouble competing with them.
I don’t like Annette Dasch (Freia). There is something in her timbre that I do not like, but that is a personal and subjective opinion. I do like Anna Samuil’s voice on the Van Zweden recording more, but neither of these ladies is a my dream Freia.
Photo：Metropolitan Opera / Marty Sohl
The only one much better cast in the van Zweden recording is Loge. Whereas Burkhard Ulrich does not sound very pleasant to me on the Rattle production- a bit shrill, although that may suit the character of Loge – Kim Begley shows that a devious character and good singing, can and do, really go together.
Rattle makes the orchestra play lightly and sparklingly. Moreover, he keeps the momentum going. Van Zweden is much more slow and more ˜long- winded”, so the performance lacks drama. In addition, the recording is far too soft. So even though I also have some reservations about Rattle: I still opt for his version.
Impression of the rehearsal by Rattle:
Trailer of van Zweden’s recording:
Basia con fuoco 